Lexpert magazine features articles and columns on developments in legal practice management, deals and lawsuits of interest in Canada, the law and business issues of interest to legal professionals and businesses that purchase legal services.
Issue link: https://digital.carswellmedia.com/i/1547685
8 www.lexpert.ca Special Promotional Feature WHEN TRADE WARS MEET THE RULE OF LAW BEYOND POLITICAL HEADLINES, CANADA-US TARIFF LITIGATION TESTS WHETHER COURTS CAN HOLD THE EXECUTIVE TO THE LAW THIS DISTINCTION, drawn nearly 250 years ago, remains at the heart of modern trade disputes. Although tariffs oen appear to derive from executive fiat, their longevity ultimately depends on law. Few recent conflicts have tested that propo- sition more visibly than the escalating tariff dispute between Canada and the US. Public attention largely focuses on political dynamics and economic consequences, but a struggle at least as important is unfolding before courts, specialized agencies, and dispute-settlement bodies charged with determining the legality of these measures. At a moment when it is tempting to conclude the centre cannot hold, the rules-based trading system has not yet yielded entirely to power politics. Litigation emerges as a principal battleground of the modern trade war. The architecture of tariff law Tariffs are not imposed in a legal vacuum: they rest on a layered architecture of constitu- tional, statutory, and treaty-based authority. In the US, art. 1, s. 8 of the Constitution grants Congress power to impose duties and regulate foreign commerce. Congress delegates tariff authority through various statutes, including the Tariff Act of 1930, the Trade Expansion Act of 1962, and the Trade Act of 1974. In Canada, Parliament's authority derives principally from ss. 91(2) and 91(3) of the Constitution Act, 1867 and is implemented through the Customs Tariff, the Customs Act, and the Special Import Measures Act. Tariffs take numerous forms, including trade remedies (unfair trade practices reme- dies and safeguard measures) and exceptional measures (authorized national-security or retaliatory measures). Most of the tariffs imposed between the US and Canada in recent history have taken the form of the former, namely (a) antidumping duties, which address imports sold at less than "normal value," and (b) countervailing duties, which offset foreign government subsidies. In the US, the Department of Commerce investigates dumping and subsidiza- tion, while the US International Trade Commission determines injury. In Canada, those functions are performed by the Canada Border Services Agency and the Canadian International Trade Tribunal, respectively. Final determinations are subject to judicial review, and where goods of another CUSMA party are involved, binational panels may take the place of domestic courts. Outside these categories, international trade agreements constrain the imposition of new tariffs. Since 1947, the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade (GATT) and, since 1995, the WTO framework have prohibited discrimina- tory duties through the most-favoured-nation principle (GATT art. 1) and duties exceeding negotiated tariff commitments (GATT art. 2). Similar principles are reflected in CUSMA, including art. 2.4, which generally prohibits new duties on originating goods. e central question in most modern trade disputes is, therefore, whether a measure falls within an authorized exception, such as an unfair trade practice remedy, safeguard, national-security, or retaliatory measure. If interpreted too broadly, however, the exception risks swal- lowing the rule. Judicial battlegrounds for the trade conflict e current Canada-US conflict has featured "A GOVERNMENT OF LAWS, AND NOT OF MEN" John Adams CONSTITUTION OF MASSACHUSETTS (1780)

