www.lexpert.ca 5
In its ruling , the SCC outlined a four-
part test for establishing that spoliation has
occurred. On a balance of probabilities, a
court must find that evidence was inten-
tionally destroyed, altered, or concealed;
that litigation was underway or expected
at the time of the destruction; that the
evidence was relevant to the litigation; and
that the evidence was destroyed, altered, or
hidden to influence the litigation.
If a court determines that spoliation has
occurred, there is a rebuttable presumption
that the destroyed evidence would have
harmed the spoliator's case. e alleged
spoliator can then challenge the finding
that they destroyed evidence. If they can't
do so successfully, the court must proceed
under the assumption that the destroyed
evidence was unfavourable to the spoliator.
Watson notes that over the last few
decades, several provincial appellate courts
have issued rulings on spoliation that have
laid out similar principles. In its 2023 deci-
sion in Trillium Power Wind Corporation
v. Ontario, for example, the Ontario Court
of Appeal ruled that there was an "ample
evidentiary basis" to support allegations
that the Ontario government had delib-
erately destroyed emails and other docu-
ments relevant to a lawsuit.
THE SSC'S SPOLIATION
RULINGS
In 1896, the high court released
its decision on the common law
doctrine of spoliation in St. Louis
v. The Queen. The case involved a party
who burned physical records so they
would be unavailable at trial.
The SCC did not address the
doctrine of spoliation again until
July 2026, in SS&C Technologies
Canada Corp. v. Bank of New York
Mellon Corp.