4 www.lexpert.ca
Feature
WHEN THE Supreme Court of Canada
released a unanimous decision this
summer in a dispute between a Canadian
data provider and the Bank of New York
Mellon, lawyers across the country were
keen to see the high court's new frame-
work for establishing spoliation – the
intentional destruction, alteration, mutila-
tion, or concealment of evidence.
A key reason for this interest was that
the SCC had not addressed the issue of
spoliation in a long time. By the time
the high court issued its ruling in SS&C
Technologies Canada Corp. v. Bank of New
York Mellon Corp. in July, its last ruling on
the spoliation doctrine was 130 years old.
at 19th-century case, St. Louis v. e
Queen, involved a man who had burned
records so they would not be available as
evidence at trial.
Needless to say, evidence can look very
different today. Over the last few decades,
businesses across Canada have overwhelm-
ingly shied from paper to electronic
records – a development that only accel-
erated during the COVID-19 pandemic,
when many businesses shut down in-person
operations and began operating virtually.
Electronic storage options, from USB flash
drives to cloud storage, have evolved and
continue to change. Destroying evidence
looks different, too; rather than, say,
Feature
SPOLIATION IN THE
21st CENTURY
THE SUPREME COURT OF CANADA UPDATED ITS SPOLIATION
FRAMEWORK FOR THE FIRST TIME IN 130 YEARS THIS SUMMER.
HERE'S WHAT BUSINESSES CAN TAKE AWAY FROM THE RULING
burning physical records, individuals can
now potentially eliminate or tamper with
evidence with the click of a button.
"I think this issue of spoliation is more
relevant today than it was in the past
because of the ease with which documents
are generated and potentially destroyed,"
says Ren Bucholz, a partner at Paliare
Roland Rosenberg Rothstein LLP, who
was part of the team that represented
SS&C in the high court case.
Despite these major shis over the past
130 years, however, the SCC's ruling says
little about how the doctrine of spoliation
specifically applies to modern evidence.
Michael Watson, a partner at Gowling WLG
who is not affiliated with either party in the
case, argues that the value of the high court's
ruling lies instead in how it affirms the way
provincial courts have approached spoliation
for years, and how it brings these approaches
together under a single framework.
"Different courts of appeal have used
different language in expressing what
the principles of spoliation are, and now
what we have is… one place where all of
this is set out," Watson says. "I consider
[SS&C Technologies Canada Corp.] to be
important not because it radically or really
much at all changes the law, but because it
sets it out for all of Canada, and in a way
that is easily understood."