Lexpert Magazine

November 2026 Litigation

Lexpert magazine features articles and columns on developments in legal practice management, deals and lawsuits of interest in Canada, the law and business issues of interest to legal professionals and businesses that purchase legal services.

Issue link: https://digital.carswellmedia.com/i/1547685

Contents of this Issue

Navigation

Page 7 of 115

6 www.lexpert.ca Feature In that ruling , the OCA cited other appel- late decisions in Ontario, Saskatchewan, and Alberta that dealt with spoliation. ese decisions explain that there is a rebuttable presumption that destroyed evidence "would have been unfavourable to the party who destroyed it"; that parties have an obligation to preserve and produce relevant documents in civil proceedings; and that spoliation occurs when a party intentionally destroys evidence "in circum- stances where a reasonable inference can be drawn that the evidence was destroyed to affect the litigation." These principles do not specifically address modern forms of evidence, such as electronic records. Still, the SCC's amal- gamation of these principles in its SS&C Technologies Canada Corp. framework provides a useful guide for companies that are involved in – or expect to be involved in – litigation today. Bucholz notes that the SCC's ruling affirmed that to establish spoliation, it must be proven that a party intention- ally destroyed evidence. The big takeaway for businesses expecting to file a lawsuit is to send out a litigation hold letter – i.e., a notice instructing the defendant to preser ve all potentially relevant docu- ments – as soon as possible. If it later turns out that the defendant has not preser ved some evidence, having a liti- gation hold letter on the record makes it easier to prove that the failure to preser ve the evidence was intentional, Bucholz says. The lesson for defendants, on the other hand, is to take litigation hold letters and their production obligations seriously. "You should ensure that notice of the claim or notice of the litigation hold letter are sent to your counsel and also to the relevant custodians within your organization, and you should ensure that you've done everything in your power to preser ve the documents, even if you disagree with the basis for the request to preser ve them," Bucholz says. The litigator adds that if companies take the appropriate steps to save relevant documents, those steps could help them defend themselves against claims that they intentionally destroyed evidence. If "there's a flood and [the documents] are lost, or somebody misses a reposi- tory of documents that should have been preser ved, and then it gets deleted, but not intentionally, that can be a defence to a claim of spoliation or an allegation of spoliation," Bucholz says. Companies should also review their data storage and retention policies. Bucholz cautions that companies could inadvertently destroy evidence if their data is regularly overwritten due to space constraints, automated procedures, or regulatory requirements. Watson agrees that companies should review these policies, adding that the poli- cies need to include provisions addressing litigation and possible litigation, particularly requirements that any individual working at a company report to senior management any indication that litigation may be coming. Assigning a specific person to oversee compli- ance with the obligation to preserve relevant evidence could also be helpful, he says. "Most people – and this includes most businesses – are surprised, maybe even shocked, when they are told by lawyers in the context of a lawsuit that they have to produce to the opposite party… docu- ments that may be harmful or even fatal to their case," Watson says. "How can that be fair ? How can we be required to produce things that are against our interests ? " Well, that is the law," Watson says. The SCC's ruling , he says, confirms this will continue to be the case. "Different courts of appeal have used different language in expressing what the principles of spoliation are, and now what we have is… one place where all of this is set out" Michael Watson GOWLING WLG "This issue of spoliation is more relevant today than it was in the past because of the ease with which documents are generated and potentially destroyed" Ren Bucholz PALIARE ROLAND ROSENBERG ROTHSTEIN LLP SAFEGUARDING DATA Bucholz cautions that companies could inadvertently destroy evidence if their data is regularly overwritten due to space constraints, automated procedures, or regulatory requirements

Articles in this issue

Links on this page

Archives of this issue

view archives of Lexpert Magazine - November 2026 Litigation