22 www.lexpert.ca
Top 10 Business Decisions
THE COMPETITION TRIBUNAL has
issued the first decision interpreting the
"public interest" leave test under s. 103.1(7)
of the Competition Act, a provision intro-
duced by recent amendments that allows
private individuals to seek leave to bring
competition law claims even when they
are not directly and substantially affected
in their own business.
Alexander Martin applied for leave to
commence proceedings against Google
and Apple, alleging that Google controls
over 90 percent of the Canadian general
search engine market and maintains that
dominance through exclusionary prac-
tices. Martin pointed to the Information
Services Agreement (ISA) between the
two companies, entered in 2016, under
which Google paid Apple US$20 billion in
2022 alone to make Google the exclusive
default search engine on Apple devices,
foreclosing competitors from distribution
MARTIN V. ALPHABET INC., GOOGLE LLC, GOOGLE
CANADA CORPORATION, APPLE INC., AND APPLE
CANADA INC.
on the more than 225 million iPhones
sold globally by Apple in 2024. He sought
orders under the abuse of dominance
provisions (s. 79) and the anti-competitive
agreements provisions (s. 90.1) of the Act.
The Competition Tribunal dismissed
the application. Adopting a three-
step approach drawn from the SCC's
public-interest standing jurisprudence, the
tribunal assessed whether the proposed
application is a substantial and genuine
competition law dispute, whether the appli-
cant has a genuine interest, and whether the
proposed proceeding is a reasonable and
effective means of determining the compe-
tition issues raised. The tribunal found
that while the issues transcended Martin's
private interests, his evidence fell short on
the second and third steps – he did not
adequately demonstrate a genuine interest
beyond being a search engine user, and
he provided no evidence of the resources,
• Alexander Martin > Berger Montague
> Albert Pelletier, Ian Literovich, and
Edwina Mayama
• Alphabet Inc., Google LLC, and Google
Canada Corporation > Davies Ward
Phillips & Vineberg LLP > Kent E.
Thomson, Elisa K. Kearney, Derek Ricci,
Steven Frankel, Chenyang Li, and Anisha
Visvanatha
• Apple Inc. and Apple Canada Inc. >
McMillan LLP > Neil Campbell, Éric
Vallières, and William Wu
• Commissioner of Competition > Justice
Canada > Paul Klippenstein and Kevin
Hong
CLIENTS > FIRMS > LAWYERS
expertise, or evidentiary plan needed to
advance the proposed proceeding.
The decision is the first to define the
boundaries of private access to compe-
tition law remedies under the reformed
Competition Act. Derek Ricci of Davies
Ward Phillips & Vineberg LLP says that, as
the very first case decided under the newly
enacted private right of action regime in
the Competition Act, the decision "set the
test that will be applied in future public-in-
terest applications." The Competition
Tribunal's application of that test makes
clear that applicants must present more
than bare allegations and demonstrate the
capacity and evidentiary foundation to
advance a proposed proceeding.