Lexpert Magazine

November 2026 Litigation

Lexpert magazine features articles and columns on developments in legal practice management, deals and lawsuits of interest in Canada, the law and business issues of interest to legal professionals and businesses that purchase legal services.

Issue link: https://digital.carswellmedia.com/i/1547685

Contents of this Issue

Navigation

Page 22 of 115

www.lexpert.ca 21 • Van Dolder's Home Team Inc. > McCarthy Tétrault LLP > Tim Lawson, Brandon Kain, Marco Fimiani, and John Gray • Frederick Baker > Achkar Law > Filip Pejovic and Jason Jagpal • Parkdale Community Legal Services and Income Security Advocacy Centre > Cavalluzzo LLP > Jackie Esmonde, Cole Eisen, and David McQuillan • Song Li > Whitten & Lublin PC > Simone Ostrowski and Benjamin Hahn • Wayfair Canada ULC > Hicks Morley Hamilton Stewart Storie LLP > Edward J. O'Dwyer and Kelly Brennan • Ontario Chamber of Commerce > Hicks Morley Hamilton Stewart Storie LLP > Andrew J. McCreary, Mari T. Maimets, and Stephanie Gellatly CLIENTS > FIRMS > LAWYERS THE ONTARIO COURT OF APPEAL has set out a framework for interpreting termi- nation clauses in employment contracts, resolving conflicting lower court decisions on what makes such clauses enforceable under the Employment Standards Act, 2000 (ESA). Tim Lawson, partner at McCarthy Tétrault LLP, says the ruling "harmonizes how Ontario courts assess the enforceability of termination clauses with the general prin- ciples of contractual interpretation," noting that it is "highly significant for employers and employees alike across the province, impacting almost any employment contract." Frederick Baker worked for Van Dolder's Home Team Inc. as its controller and head of finance. His employment contract permitted the company to terminate his employment "at any time, without just cause" upon providing only the minimum notice or payment in lieu of notice required by the ESA. When Van Dolder's terminated Baker without cause in March 2023, he challenged the clause's enforceability, arguing that the phrase BAKER V. VAN DOLDER'S HOME TEAM INC., 2026 ONCA 568 "at any time" was inconsistent with the ESA because the statute prohibits termi- nation at certain times, such as upon the conclusion of an employee's leave or as a reprisal. The motion judge agreed with Baker and found the termination clause unen- forceable. In the companion case, Li v. Wayfair Canada ULC, virtually identical language – permitting termination "at any time and for any reason" – was upheld as valid. The divergent outcomes illustrated a persistent split in the lower courts. The court acknowledged that employ- ment contracts must be interpreted differ- ently from other commercial agreements, noting "the desirability of protecting the interests of vulnerable employees" and the "pronounced power imbalance between employers and employees." However, the court held that interpreta- tion remains a contractual exercise aimed at discerning the parties' objective inten- tions from the contract as a whole and its surrounding circumstances. The court found that the termination provisions in both contracts reflected "an objective intention to comply with the minimum standards in the ESA applicable upon the termination of employment." The court allowed Van Dolder's appeal and dismissed Li's appeal, upholding the termination clauses in both contracts. The decision aims to resolve the diver- gent outcomes that had marked the lower court jurisprudence on ESA-compliant termination provisions. Lawson adds that the decision "received extensive coverage in the legal media and months of commentary online," and that the plaintiffs plan to seek leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada.

Articles in this issue

Links on this page

Archives of this issue

view archives of Lexpert Magazine - November 2026 Litigation