Lexpert Magazine

November 2026 Litigation

Lexpert magazine features articles and columns on developments in legal practice management, deals and lawsuits of interest in Canada, the law and business issues of interest to legal professionals and businesses that purchase legal services.

Issue link: https://digital.carswellmedia.com/i/1547685

Contents of this Issue

Navigation

Page 21 of 115

20 www.lexpert.ca Top 10 Business Decisions • SS&C Technologies Canada Corp. > Paliare Roland Rosenberg Rothstein LLP > Chris G. Paliare, Ren Bucholz, Glynnis Hawe, Catherine Dunne, and Ellie McPhee-Mullins • Bank of New York Mellon Corp. > McCarthy Tétrault LLP, Lenczner Slaght LLP > Eli Mogil, Brandon Kain, Erin Chesney, Aya Schechner, Thomas Curry, and Brian Kolenda CLIENTS > FIRMS > LAWYERS WHEN A Canadian data provider discov- ered its bank counterparty had been funnelling licensed pricing data to affili- ates for free, it explicitly requested that the bank preserve evidence of how the data had been redistributed. The bank refused. The ensuing litigation reached the Supreme Court of Canada, which unanimously established a test for spoli- ation and held that once spoliation is proved, a mandatory rebuttable presump- tion arises that the destroyed evidence was unfavourable to the spoliator's case. Courts have no discretion to decline to draw that inference. As Chris Paliare of Paliare Roland Rosenberg Rothstein LLP notes, the case "marks the Supreme Court of Canada's first pronouncement on spoliation – the intentional destruction or concealment of evidence to subvert the truth-finding process – since 1896." In 1999, SS&C Technologies entered into a data services agreement with the Bank of New York Mellon that prohib- ited the bank from sharing, redistrib- uting, or selling the data to subsidiaries or affiliates. A joint venture between the bank and a Canadian financial institution held a separate agreement with SS&C, which the joint venture terminated in 2011, claiming it no longer needed the services. In 2016, SS&C discovered that the joint venture had continued to receive data from the bank for free after termina- tion, thereby circumventing the licensing scheme. SS&C terminated the agreement and sued for breach of contract. The trial judge found the bank breached its agreement and awarded US$5,696,850 in damages using a "rateable approach," drawing two adverse inferences against the bank for its failure to produce and preserve documents – but stopped short of making an express finding of spoli- ation. The Court of Appeal made that finding but upheld the damage award. Writing for the court, Justices Côté and Moreau held that the bank committed spoliation and that the trial judge's infer- ences were too weak to remedy the miscon- SS&C TECHNOLOGIES CANADA CORP. V. BANK OF NEW YORK MELLON CORP., 2026 SCC 29 duct. The court set out a four-part test: the evidence was intentionally destroyed or concealed, litigation was ongoing or reasonably contemplated, the evidence was relevant, and a reasonable inference arises that the destruction was meant to affect the litigation. Paliare said the bank's "inten- tional destruction of critically important documents, which it failed to preserve in the face of a document preservation notice," precluded the plaintiffs from estab- lishing damages for breaches of contract extending over 17 years; he added that "the Supreme Court's unanimous decision sends a strong message to litigants that such cheating, which undermines the integ- rity of the administration of justice, will not be tolerated and will result in manda- tory and significant adverse inferences against the spoliator." Eli Mogil, partner at McCarthy Tétrault LLP, describes the deci- sion as "a highly significant case," adding that "the decision will affect the conduct of all litigation, especially complex matters between sophisticated parties with docu- mentary records going back many years, and Canadian businesses must review their document preservation and data retention policies in light of it." The court allowed the appeal and remitted the matter for reas- sessment of damages.

Articles in this issue

Links on this page

Archives of this issue

view archives of Lexpert Magazine - November 2026 Litigation