Lexpert magazine features articles and columns on developments in legal practice management, deals and lawsuits of interest in Canada, the law and business issues of interest to legal professionals and businesses that purchase legal services.
Issue link: https://digital.carswellmedia.com/i/1547685
28 www.lexpert.ca Top 10 Business Decisions 1086289 ONTARIO INC. (URBAN ELECTRICAL CONTRACTORS) V. WELLAND (CITY), 2026 ONCA 352 THIS DECISION groups four appeals under a single citation, each raising common issues about the disclosure of partial settlement agreements in multi- party civil litigation. Among them is Evertz Technologies Limited v. Providius Corp. (COA-24-CV-1252), in which the court upheld a stay of a $600 million claim after the plaintiff failed to disclose a partial settlement agreement. Anu Koshal, partner at McCarthy Tétrault LLP and counsel for the Providius respondents, calls it "one of the largest cases to be dismissed under the doctrine of abuse of process in Canada." A five-judge panel of the Ontario Court of Appeal overruled its own 2018 decision in Handley Estate v. DTE Industries Limited. Under the Handley Estate rule, parties who entered a partial settlement that changed the adversarial landscape of the litigation were required to disclose the agreement immediately to non-settling parties and the court. Failure to do so automatically constituted an abuse of process – regard- less of whether any actual prejudice resulted – and the sole remedy was a stay of proceedings. The rule applied automat- ically and without exception. The court concluded that Handley Estate was wrongly decided. It held that the rule departed from the principles governing the doctrine of abuse of process, which has long required a contextual and discre- tionary assessment directed to whether the impugned conduct results in "unfairness, prejudice, oppression, or otherwise under- mines the integrity of the administration of justice." Any remedy, the court held, must be "proportionate to the nature and consequences of the abuse." The court also addressed the interaction between the common law and the recently enacted Rule 49.14 of the Rules of Civil Procedure, which now imposes specific disclosure obli- gations for settlement agreements. The decision replaces the automatic sanc- tion under Handley Estate with a contextual framework that requires courts to assess whether non-disclosure caused actual unfairness or prejudice before imposing a remedy, and to tailor that remedy propor- tionately to the circumstances. • Rounthwaite Dick & Hadley Architects Inc. (COA-24-CV-0855) > Lundy Levy & Eski Barristers > Andrew Lundy and Zohar Levy • The Corporation of the City of Kawartha Lakes (COA-24-CV-0938) > Borden Ladner Gervais LLP > Kevin A. McGivney and Natalie D. Kolos • Thrive Capital Management Ltd., Thrive Uplands Ltd., 2699010 Ontario Inc., and 2699011 Ontario Inc. (COA-24-CV-1159) > Lerners LLP; Scher Law Professional Corporation > Earl A. Cherniak, K.C., William Pepall, Rebecca Shoom, and Hugh Scher • Evertz Technologies Ltd. and Evertz Microsystems Limited (COA-24-CV-1252) > Orr Taylor LLP > James C. Orr and Jonathan H.W. Careen • The Corporation of the City of Welland (COA-24-CV-0855); Cody Howran and Christine Fournier (COA-24-CV-0938) > Dewart Gleason LLP > Sean Dewart and Brett Hughes • Cydahlia Howran, by her Litigation Guardian, Jennifer Freeman, and Jennifer Freeman personally (COA-24-CV-0938) > Lundy Levy & Eski Barristers > Evan Rankin • Noble 1324 Queen Inc., Michael Hyman, Giuseppe Anastasio, Noble Developments Corporation, Hampshire and Associates Incorporated, Noble 12826 Leslie Corp., Wilshire Holdings Inc., Noble 376 Derry Corp., Nobel 390 Derry Corp., 2704536 Ontario Inc., 2724136 Ontario Inc., Hampshire Holdings Inc., Azan Homes Inc., Lisa Susan Anastasio, Guiseppe Anastasio Jr., Sandra Azan-Hyman, Justin Hyman, Alan Hyman and Morris Hyman (COA-24-CV-1159) > Tyr LLP > Jason Wadden, Michael O'Brien, and Aditi Gupta • Providius Corp., Tony Zare (a/k/a Antony Zarezadeqan), Ayman Al Khatib, and Jackson Wiegman (COA-24-CV-1252) > McCarthy Tétrault LLP > Anu Koshal, Rachel Chan, and Almut MacDonald CLIENTS > FIRMS > LAWYERS

