34 www.lexpert.ca
Top 10 Business Decisions
LIN V. UBER CANADA INC., 2025 FCA 183
A PROPOSED class action alleging
that Uber engages in "drip pricing" –
representing a price for its food delivery
service that is not attainable due to
additional fees charged – has been
stayed in favour of arbitration by the
Federal Court of Appeal. The practice
is alleged to be contrary to s. 52 of the
Competition Act.
Arthur Lin commenced a proposed
class proceeding in Federal Court against
Uber Canada Inc. and related entities,
arguing that Uber Eats' online platform
displays a base price and then adds fees
at checkout, rendering the advertised
price unattainable. When Lin opened
his Uber Eats account, he agreed to a
contract containing a mandatory arbitra-
tion clause that directs disputes to the
ADR Institute of Canada (ADRIC).
Lin challenged the enforceability of the
arbitration clause on three grounds: that
provincial consumer protection legisla-
tion, particularly Ontario's Consumer
Protection Act, 2002, overrides the
clause; that the clause is "incapable of
being performed" because ADRIC does
not adjudicate class proceedings; and that
the clause is unconscionable.
In a unanimous decision, the court
applied the two-part test set out in the
Supreme Court's decision in Peace River
Hydro Partners v. Petrowest Corp. and found
that Uber had established an arguable
case that all four technical prerequisites
for a stay had been met. Turning to the
second branch, the court held that Lin
failed to establish on a balance of prob-
abilities that any statutory exception
prevented a stay. The court confirmed
• Arthur Lin > Evolink Law Group > Simon
Lin
• Uber Canada Inc., Uber Technologies, Inc.,
Uber Portier Canada Inc., and Uber Castor
Canada Inc. > McCarthy Tétrault LLP >
Gillian Kerr, Patrick Williams, and Tanner
Lorenson
CLIENTS > FIRMS > LAWYERS
that provincial consumer protection
legislation does not apply to proceedings
under the Competition Act in the Federal
Court, and that the arbitration clause was
neither incapable of performance nor
unconscionable.
The decision clarifies that Federal Court
proceedings under the Competition Act
are not subject to provincial consumer
protection overrides, and that the "legis-
lative and judicial preference for holding
parties to arbitration agreements," as
stated in Peace River, applies absent a
clear statutory exception.