32 www.lexpert.ca
Top 10 Business Decisions
HVITVED V. HOME DEPOT OF CANADA INC., 2026
BCCA 39
THE BRITISH COLUMBIA COURT OF
APPEAL has upheld the certification of
a privacy class action against Home Depot
of Canada Inc., arising from the retailer's
transfer of customer email addresses and
purchasing information to Meta Platforms
Inc. (the operator of Facebook), which
Home Depot used, among other things,
to assess whether its Facebook advertising
campaigns were generating in-store sales.
From October 2018 to October 2022,
Home Depot used Meta's offline conver-
sion tool. When customers provided
their email addresses to receive an elec-
tronic receipt, Home Depot transferred
a hashed version of those addresses
– along with other purchase informa-
tion – to Meta. If the hashed email
matched an address Meta already held,
Meta could link the purchase data to a
specific Facebook account. Home Depot
may have shared as many as 6.85 million
unique hashed email addresses with Meta
during this period.
Lasse Hvitved, a British Columbia
customer, brought a class action alleging
breach of privacy legislation in British
Columbia, Saskatchewan, Manitoba, and
Newfoundland and Labrador. The cham-
bers judge certified the privacy claim but
struck the breach-of-contract, intrusion
upon seclusion, and unjust enrichment
claims. Both sides appealed.
The court dismissed both the appeal
and the cross-appeal. On the breach-of-
contract claim, the court agreed with the
chambers judge that the pleading was
bound to fail, as it relied on generic asser-
tions and contained no material facts about
how the alleged contracts were formed
or the basis for the claimed express or
implied terms. Alexandra Cocks, partner
at McCarthy Tétrault LLP and counsel
for Home Depot on the appeal, says the
• Lasse Hvitved > CFM Lawyers LLP > Jamie
Thornback and Oliver Pulleyblank
• Home Depot of Canada Inc. > McCarthy
Tétrault LLP > Alexandra Cocks and Connor
Bildfell
CLIENTS > FIRMS > LAWYERS
decision "illustrates how courts can strike
a large part of a claim at the certification
stage and offers important guidance on
what is required to properly plead a breach
of contract claim."
On the privacy claim, the court rejected
Home Depot's argument that the contex-
tual nature of the privacy inquiry precluded
a finding of commonality among class
members. It also declined to narrow the
class, finding Home Depot's objections to
including non-Facebook users and corpo-
rate customers without merit at this stage,
and left open for trial whether a corpora-
tion can advance a claim under provincial
privacy legislation that does not expressly
exclude it.
Cocks describes the ruling as "a key BC
Court of Appeal decision in privacy class
actions, a growing area of litigation."