30 www.lexpert.ca
Top 10 Business Decisions
EMOND V. TRILLIUM MUTUAL INSURANCE CO.,
2026 SCC 3
AFTER A flood destroyed their home,
Stephen and Claudette Emond turned to
their insurer for the cost of rebuilding
– including the additional expense of
complying with a local conservation
authority's requirements. Their insurer,
Trillium Mutual Insurance Company,
acknowledged coverage for the loss
but disputed whether those compliance
costs fell within the policy's guaranteed
rebuilding cost (GRC) endorsement,
which promises to pay for rebuilding using
current building techniques even when the
cost exceeds the policy's stated insurance
amount. The Supreme Court of Canada,
in a 7-1-1 decision, sided with the insurer.
The application judge had ruled in
favour of the Emonds, declaring that the
GRC endorsement entitled them to full
rebuilding costs without limitation. The
Court of Appeal reversed, finding that the
compliance cost exclusion – which excludes
"increased costs of repair or replacement
due to operation of any law regulating the
zoning, demolition, repair, or construction
of buildings and their related services" –
applied to limit the insurer's liability.
Writing for the majority, Justice Rowe
held that when the insurance contract is read
as a whole, the compliance cost exclusion
unambiguously applies despite the GRC
endorsement. Endorsements, the court
emphasized, "are not self-contained and
standalone contracts disconnected from the
insurance policy of which they form a part."
The majority also held that the nullification
of the coverage doctrine – which prevents
an exclusion from completely defeating the
purpose of the purchased coverage – did
not apply because the GRC endorsement
still provided meaningful value beyond the
compliance costs at issue.
The decision establishes that endorse-
ments to a standard form insurance policy
do not displace the policy's exclusion
clauses unless clear language indicates
• Stephen and Claudette Emond > Connolly
Obagi LLP > Joseph Y. Obagi, Elizabeth A.
Quigley, and Wayne J. Fryer
• Trillium Mutual Insurance Co. > Gowling
WLG (Canada) LLP > Pasquale C. Peloso,
Jaime Wilson, James Plotkin, and Darren
Johnston
• Insurance Bureau of Canada > Blake,
Cassels & Graydon LLP > Jeff Galway,
Christopher DiMatteo, and Lilian Esene
• Ontario Trial Lawyers Association > Oatley
Vigmond LLP > Brian Cameron and Liane
Brown
• Canadian Association of Mutual Insurance
Companies, Ontario Mutual Insurance
Association, and Farm Mutual Reinsurance
Plan Inc. > McCarthy Tétrault LLP > Atrisha
Lewis, Akiva Stern, Mathew Zaia, and
William G. Scott
CLIENTS > FIRMS > LAWYERS
otherwise. Joseph Obagi of Connolly
Obagi LLP, one of the lawyers who repre-
sented the Emonds, told Canadian Lawyer
that "the majority missed an opportunity
to hold insurance companies to a higher
standard," adding that homeowners need
to carefully review their policies because
declaration-page language like "guaran-
teed replacement cost coverage" may not
deliver what it appears to promise.