Lexpert magazine features articles and columns on developments in legal practice management, deals and lawsuits of interest in Canada, the law and business issues of interest to legal professionals and businesses that purchase legal services.
Issue link: https://digital.carswellmedia.com/i/1547685
www.lexpert.ca 19 THE SUPREME COURT OF CANADA has upheld leave for an investor to pursue a statutory cause of action against Lundin Mining Corporation and several of its offi- cers and directors for alleged failure to make timely disclosure of material changes under Ontario's Securities Act. Brandon Kain, partner at McCarthy Tétrault LLP, says the ruling stands as "a landmark Supreme Court of Canada decision" on issues "of critical importance to capital markets." In October 2017, Lundin detected pit wall instability at its Candelaria copper mine in Chile – a site that accounted for between 55 and 60 percent of the company's total sales revenue. Within days, a localized rockslide sent roughly 600,000 to 700,000 tonnes of waste material down a slope, restricting access to a key mining phase. Lundin shut down at least part of the mine and revised its 2018 copper production forecast downward by 20 percent. Rather than disclosing these devel- opments immediately, Lundin included them in a routine operational update about a month later, on November 29, 2017. The next day, its share price dropped 16 percent – a loss of more than $1 billion in market capitalization. Dov Markowich, who purchased Lundin shares after the instability and rock- slide occurred but before the company disclosed them, commenced a proposed class proceeding alleging that the company breached its timely disclosure obligations. The motion judge refused leave, concluding that neither event constituted a "material change" in the company's business, opera- tions, or capital because Lundin continued to operate as a mining company. The Court of Appeal disagreed and granted leave. The SCC, in an 8-1 decision written by Justice Jamal, dismissed Lundin's appeal, holding that the motion judge relied on overly restrictive definitions of "change," "business," "oper- ations," and "capital" – terms the Ontario legislature intentionally left undefined to allow flexible, contextual application across industries and corporate structures. The decision affirms that the terms in the "material change" definition must be inter- preted contextually, and that operational disruptions with demonstrable market impact may trigger the obligation to disclose "forth- with" rather than as part of periodic updates. As Luis Sarabia of Davies Ward Phillips & Vineberg LLP observed, the SCC held that a "material change" requiring immediate disclo- sure "should be read broadly and in context, not limited to 'core' or 'fundamental' LUNDIN MINING CORP. V. MARKOWICH, 2025 SCC 39 CLIENTS > FIRMS > LAWYERS • Lundin Mining Corp., Paul K. Conibear, Marie Inkster, Paul McRae, Lukas H. Lundin, and Stephen Gatley > Cassels Brock & Blackwell LLP > Lara Jackson, John M. Picone, Kate Byers, and Laura Cloutier • Dov Markowich > Groia & Company Professional Corp., Strosberg Wingfield Sasso LLP > Joseph Groia, Jay Strosberg, Scott Robinson, and Yona Gal • Canadian Coalition for Good Governance > Torys LLP > John A. Fabello, Gillian B. Dingle, and Lauren Nickerson • Ontario Securities Commission > Ontario Securities Commission > Aaron Dantowitz and Charlie Pettypiece • Mining Association of Canada > Davies Ward Phillips & Vineberg LLP > Luis Sarabia, Jonathan Bilyk, and Matthew Howe • CFA Societies Canada Inc. > Lenczner Slaght LLP > Monique Jilesen, Brian Kolenda, and Devon R. Kapoor • LiUNA Pension Fund of Central and Eastern Canada > Koskie Minsky LLP > Vlad Calina and Caitlin Leach • Insurance Bureau of Canada > McCarthy Tétrault LLP > Dana M. Peebles and Valérie Lord • Canadian Chamber of Commerce > McCarthy Tétrault LLP > Wendy Berman, Brandon Kain, and Aya Schechner changes." Monique Jilesen of Lenczner Slaght LLP, counsel to the intervener CFA Societies Canada Inc., says the decision "clarifies that the materiality threshold is not to be applied narrowly to limit disclo- sure, but rather serves to deter informational asymmetry between issuers and investors across Canadian capital markets."

