Lexpert Magazine

November 2026 Litigation

Lexpert magazine features articles and columns on developments in legal practice management, deals and lawsuits of interest in Canada, the law and business issues of interest to legal professionals and businesses that purchase legal services.

Issue link: https://digital.carswellmedia.com/i/1547685

Contents of this Issue

Navigation

Page 12 of 115

www.lexpert.ca 11 In its decision in Weinstein v. Sirius XM Canada Inc., the court explained that the plaintiff had failed to plead a valid cause of action, a requirement for certification under Ontario's class actions regime. The court noted that the plaintiff had origi- nally argued that SiriusXM had violated the Competition Act's prohibition of drip pricing. However, the plaintiff was forced to withdraw that claim after SiriusXM successfully argued that the subscription agreement terms required customers to arbitrate disputes over their subscriptions. The plaintiff was forced to move forward with other claims under the Consumer Protection Act, which the court said could not succeed. In the second case, Kuling v. Ticketmaster, the plaintiff purchased a ticket for a comedy show through Ticketmaster. She argued that while the face value of the ticket was $74.50, she was later charged additional non-optional fees – including a service fee, a facility charge, and a delivery and order processing fee – in violation of the Competition Act. But the Federal Court declined to certify the class action. The court found that both the order processing fee and the face-value price of the tickets were displayed simulta- neously and in plain view. "Even a generous reading of the pleadings cannot charac- terize this situation as prohibited 'drip pricing,'" the court said, adding the lawsuit had "no reasonable prospect of success." This latter decision has helped clarify what does and doesn't qualify as drip pricing, Williams says. He adds that the two recent rulings also demonstrate that "notwithstanding this new provision of the Competition Act targeting drip pricing, it's not an automatic path to certification." Jurisdictional issues in cases alleging wrongdoing that occurred outside Canada Byron Shaw, a partner at McCarthy Tétrault whose litigation practice includes class actions, says a spate of recent cases has seen courts and litigants grappling with a specific set of jurisdictional questions: "when, and in what circumstances, plain- tiffs can sue and certify a class [against] a business that is partially or wholly online." Shaw is part of a team that recently argued one of these cases before the Supreme Court of Canada. In NHK Spring Co., Ltd., et al. v. Tony Cheung, et al., the high court is tasked with considering whether British Columbia's courts have jurisdic- tion over a class action lawsuit that alleges Canadian consumers were harmed by a supposed price-fixing scheme that inflated the price of suspension assemblies, a type of computer hard-drive component. The jurisdictional issues arose because the manufacturers are headquartered in Japan and allegedly made and imple- mented the price-fixing agreements entirely outside Canada. The case essentially deals "with the scope of the Competition Act and whether it reaches foreign defendants who are engaged in what we would say is a totally foreign alleged price-fixing conspiracy," Shaw says. He points to another class action that engages similar issues. In Clare v. Meta Platforms, two authors and a translator brought a proposed class action against Meta, alleging the tech company used their copyrighted works to train its large language models. Meta, which is headquartered in California, moved to strike, arguing that the Federal Court lacked jurisdiction over the claims. This case, and other recent copyright cases involving large language models, raise "really interesting issues of whether Canadian copyright laws have been infringed," Shaw says. They consider "whether the courts can take jurisdiction solely on the basis that the material is alleged to have been copied under Canadian law, in circumstances where the servers or the data scraping that is alleged is maybe not in Canada at all, or the Canadian presence is minimal to nonexistent." "Notwithstanding this new provision of the Competition Act targeting drip pricing, it's not an automatic path to ceritification" Patrick Williams MCCARTHY TÉTRAULT LLP "[Recent cases consider] when, and in what circumstances, plaintiffs can sue and certify a class [against] a business that is partially or wholly online" Byron Shaw MCCARTHY TÉTRAULT LLP

Articles in this issue

Links on this page

Archives of this issue

view archives of Lexpert Magazine - November 2026 Litigation